x
Breaking News
More () »

Man's Body was Buried Twice Before Being Dumped in SC Lake

The sheriff called the case "one of the most profoundly senseless killings" he's seen since he's been sheriff.

Sumter, SC (WLTX) - Sumter County deputies say a fatal shooting victim was buried and moved twice before his body was ultimately dumped in Lake Marion.

Sumter County Sheriff Anthony Dennis gave an update Monday into the death of 24-year-old Jerry Lamars Johnson.

Dennis called the case "one of the most profoundly senseless killings" he's seen since he's been sheriff.

Johnson had been reported missing on April 24. A day later, a fisherman found his body in a cove near Indian Bluff Park in Lake Marion in Orangeburg County.

Credit: Family photo
Jerry Lamars Johnson

Johnson died of multiple gunshot wounds, Dennis said.

Johnson's family was at the press conference and said it's been tough dealing with the loss.

"We're very heartbroken at this situation right here," said Johnson's uncle. "We never though something like this would happen."

His family says that Johnson was a fun loving man with two kids.

"He loved to have fun, be around friends. He was just a good all-around person. He had a good heart. If you needed someone to talk to, he's there for you. If you need something, he's there and got your back," said Johnson's uncle.

Johnson will leave behind a eight and five-year-old child.

On Friday, 31-year-old Stephen Stinnette was arrested and charged with murder in Johnson's death after a a short chase in Richland County.

Credit: Sumter County Sheriff's Office

Officers believe Stinnette shot and killed Johnson, who Dennis said called an 'acquaintance' of the victim.' Investigators say he buried the victim in a part of the county, but for some reason became suspicious that someone may have been told of the location. Johnson was then buried in a second location, but ultimately was moved to Lake Marion.

Dennis said there had been a 'day or two' between the burials and the discovery of Johnson's body.

Three people have been charged with accessory after the fact in the case: 57-year-old Lisa Avins, 36-year-old Kimberly McFaddin Mcleod, and 36-year-old Andrew Thomas Scurry. Dennis said those three had knowledge of the crime, and assisted with the moving of the body.

Credit: Sumter County Sheriff's Office

Avins is Stinnette's mother.

Officers are still searching for one other suspect: 32-year-old Anthony Dustin Dill, also wanted for accessory after the fact. Dill is described as having brown hair and blue eyes. He stands 5'10" and weighs approximately 140 lbs.

Credit: Sumter County Sheriff's Office

Johnson's family says they're glad law enforcement is tracking down people in this case.

"We know there's other connections so by them doing that, it can bring all of them out. Get them all. It's wrong. Once you lose life, that's it. You don't get it back. That's the biggest thing," said Johnson's uncle.

The motive in the crime remains under investigation.

Anyone with information in the case is asked to call Crimestoppers at 1-888-CRIME-SC.

Before You Leave, Check This Out